Nobody Wants This Season 2 Review: Kristen Bell & Adam Brody Explore the Complexities of Love and Faith in a Modern Rom-Com

Netflix’s Nobody Wants This returns for a second season, and once again, Kristen Bell and Adam Brody deliver charm, humor, and heart in a story about love, identity, and compromise. Created by Erin Foster, the romantic comedy series dives deeper into the relationship of an interfaith couple — agnostic podcast host Joanne (Bell) and modern rabbi Noah (Brody) — as they navigate the often messy “happily ever after.”

Plot: A Honeymoon Phase That Feels Familiar

A year after audiences fell for Joanne and Noah’s unique chemistry, Season 2 finds them learning what it means to merge their two very different worlds. From blending families to balancing careers, the couple attempts to find harmony — with Noah starting a new chapter as a rabbi and Joanne integrating him into her podcast world.

But this season doesn’t just center on the main couple — it expands its scope to include their siblings, Morgan (Justine Lupe) and Sasha (Timothy Simons), who face their own relationship challenges.

Writing & Direction: Smart, Witty, and a Touch Repetitive

With new showrunners Jenni Konner (Girls) and Bruce Eric Kaplan (Six Feet Under), Season 2 takes on a slightly more grounded tone. The trademark wit remains intact, but there’s more emotional vulnerability as each character confronts what they truly want in love.

The season still revolves around the lingering question from Season 1 — will Joanne ever convert to Judaism? The show handles the theme of faith with humor and sensitivity, though the finale feels like a creative step backward, echoing the beats of the first season rather than breaking new ground.

Performances: Kristen Bell and Adam Brody Shine Again

Bell and Brody continue to dazzle with effortless chemistry and nuanced performances. Their dynamic feels authentic — equal parts funny, frustrating, and endearing.

Supporting performances add real warmth to the season: Tovah Feldshuh as Noah’s strong-willed mother, Arian Moayed as Dr. Andy, and Jackie Tohn as Esther stand out. Seth Rogen makes a hilarious cameo as a progressive rabbi, while Brody’s real-life wife, Leighton Meester, appears as Joanne’s rival, Abby — a scene-stealing guest turn.

However, some secondary characters, including the always delightful D’Arcy Carden and Sherry Cola, could have been used more effectively.

Final Verdict: Thoughtful, Funny, and Relatable

Season 2 of Nobody Wants This strikes a fine balance between humor and heartfelt exploration of modern relationships. While it occasionally revisits old territory, the series still offers plenty of insight into the highs and lows of love in the digital age.

With its relatable characters and witty dialogue, this rom-com remains binge-worthy — and deserving of a third season.

⭐ Rating: 3.5/5